On 23/06/15 22:59, Roland Haas wrote:
Hello all,
Present were: Peter, Steve, Christine, Ian, Elo, Matt, Roland
Tickets: 1667 include elliptic solver:
- several options present themselves (1) use CactusEllitpic (2) use new
arrangement Elliptic (3) use a arrangement collecting the author's thorns (4) postpone the decision
- Roland objects to adding the solver to CactusElliptic since it is
explicitly tied to Carpet and Carpet is not part of Cactus
- a general issue exists in that we either have CactusXXX arrangements
or EinsteinXXX arrangements but no neutral XXX arrangement
Thanks Roland for summing up nicely the result of the discussion. It is true that historical reasons are creating a bit of an impasse with arrangements named *Elliptic: the existing CactusElliptic implies more about its thorns than the fact that they apply to elliptic problems; on the other hand, the creation of additional *Elliptic arrangements would make life harder for (and potentially hide tools from) users who are just looking for an elliptic solver.
I am now leaning towards a mix of (3) and (4), perhaps under the form of a *Thorns or *Development arrangement (replace * with "Cosmo", or my current institution, or any other meaningful prefix). It seems to me that arrangements named this way have been used as incubators for newborn thorns, which may or may not be moved elsewhere once it's clear where (or whether at all) they belong inside Cactus or the ET.
For instance, would anyone object to a CataniaThorns arrangement?
ET workshop: There will be an update email to the mailing list with instructions concerning on how to ask for time for a regular talk and how to sign up for lightning talks.
Roland made me notice that there was never a written call for talks for ET, so it's worth repeating here what we mentioned in past calls: if you have something you'd like to present at the ET workshop, please get in touch with either me or Oleg Korobkin. There will also be the opportunity to sign up for spontaneous, lighning talks on the first day of the workshop, but these will only give you about 5 minutes to pitch your project. If you need more time, please get in touch now.
Best, Eloisa