Hi,
in the process of making GRHydro work out of the box with microphysical EOS, I would like to introduce the electron fraction Y_e (a HydroBase variable) as a variable that is explicitly evolved via a conserved variable consY_e = dens * Y_e by GRHydro (by setting Y_e_evolution_method = "GRHydro").
Previously, Y_e was evolved as the first of the advected scalar tracers. This is currently broken, since Y_e in HydroBase and the first tracer are not mapped to on another. The tracer variables will (in the future) be needed to consistently evolve mass fractions of various elements (for use in a low-density EOS and in a nuclear reaction network) that must sum up to one without Y_e. Moreover, in nuclear statistical equilibrium, Y_e is the only compositional variable needed.
Hence, it makes sense to promote Y_e to special status.
Please speak up if you have objections.
- Christian
Hi,
On Mon, Oct 25, 2010 at 08:37:56AM -0700, Christian D. Ott wrote:
The tracer variables will (in the future) be needed to consistently evolve mass fractions of various elements (for use in a low-density EOS and in a nuclear reaction network) that must sum up to one without Y_e.
We should at that time probably also talk about a special status for them, leaving the tracers as general purpose tracers. But we don't need to discuss that now.
Hence, it makes sense to promote Y_e to special status.
Please speak up if you have objections.
I don't object, assuming that this can be disabled, and is by default.
As to the timing: please wait with this change until after the next release of the ET (which should happen soonish)?
Frank
users@lists.einsteintoolkit.org
-
Christian D. Ott -
Frank Loeffler